Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Will the Real Subsidiarity Principle Please Stand Up?


In yesterday's post, Deck Chairs, I pointed out that the real problem in our church is the need to refocus on mission, ministry, and evangelism.  Those are things that happen mainly on the local level.  Yet we need to think carefully about how the churchwide structure can empower the whole church for mission.  My next three posts will talk about these questions:
  • How can a Church Center staff be best used to empower mission, ministry, and evangelism in today's world?
  • What should the Church Center NOT be spending money on?
  • How can we awaken the whole church for mission, ministry, and evangelism?

Today's post is about the first question.  What can the churchwide structure do to empower the whole church for mission, ministry and evangelism?  

Let’s start with the presenting problem:  the proposed budget for 2013-2015.

In the ongoing budget discussion, two major principles have been advanced to reduce The Episcopal Church’s over-inflated and unsustainable budget. 

  • Bishop Stacy Sauls, the Church Center’s Chief Operating Officer, advanced the first argument in his presentation to the House of Bishops, when he argued that “overhead” was too high, and proposed that we slash overhead by realigning the governance structures of the church.  This would require a constitutional convention to change the format of General Convention and the many canonically required CCABs and other bodies.
  • Since that time, the discussion has advanced to another argument: subsidiarity (it’s all the rage these days).  Many people have talked about this idea, and the Standing Commission on Structure proposes to enshrine it in our polity in proposed resolution A090, which asks us to embrace subsidiarity as a fundamental principle of our polity.  “Subsidiarity” can be understood to mean that ministry is most effectively done at the local level, and “higher” levels in the hierarchy should only do the things that are most appropriate for them, generally the things that “lower” levels cannot do. 

Subsidiarity is a hallmark of Anglicanism.  We believe, in general, that ministry should be locally adapted and locally managed.  Yet we are gathered into larger structures for a number of reasons, and among them is this: because together, we can do some things better than we can do alone.  A churchwide structure truly can empower local ministry by gathering people together in large groups to teach and learn, by pooling resources to provide shared resources for all, and by providing networks of experts that can speak, consult, and inspire at the local level. 

So I don’t think that the subsidiarity principle gives us carte blanche to go cutting all program expenses from the churchwide budget.  I think that it requires us to think carefully about what a churchwide structure can do effectively, and use our funds strategically to make those things happen. 

Let me give you an example of what a churchwide structure can do from the perspective of one network I have been involved in for the last 6 years: The Episcopal Network for Stewardship (TENS).  (I have just finished my term as a TENS board member.)  TENS is an independent churchwide network of people who are expert in and passionate about stewardship, providing stewardship conferences, a resource-rich stewardship website, and stewardship speakers at diocesan and regional conferences and seminaries.

The TEC Program Officer for Stewardship serves as a member of the TENS board, and has been able to help TENS network across the church.  She has also been able to use her program budget to help fund some particular initiatives of TENS, such as the development of TENS’ new website (www.tens.org), which provides hands-on, easily accessed tools for stewardship, to help parishes do a better job with stewardship, without requiring local ministers to reinvent the wheel. 

Now personally, I would like to see a whole churchwide office full of people who create, support and empower networks that do local ministry, without requiring local ministers to reinvent the wheel.  I would like to see people getting passionate about evangelism, Christian Formation, church planting, stewardship, Latino ministries, and on and on, because of the network-building that Church Center people do. 

I would like to see this happen through the work of Network Builders who empower ministry, rather than Program Officers who are experts in ministry.  As The Rev. Dr. Dwight Zcheile says in his article “General Convention in Context” (quoted in the Blue Book report of the Standing Committee on Mission and Evangelism): 

We now live in an age of participatory networks rather than centralized bureaucracies. How can General Convention be reimagined to support learning, innovation, networking, and renewal among peers in mission at the grass roots? One of the hallmarks of Anglicanism is its adaptability as the context changes. Today is a moment calling for major adaptation if the church is to live into its name as the Domestic and Foreign Missionary Society.

I would add that this networking concept applies not just to General Convention, but also to the whole concept of a denominational “headquarters.”

Specifically, I propose that we create an Office of Networking to find ways to creatively network people for mission in the church.  Instead of Program Officers in charge of specific areas of expertise at the Church Center, we would have Networkers.  The Networkers would work with groups like TENS and Forma that are already active, helping to empower their work.  And in areas where we don’t have active networks, or have nascent networks, like evangelism or congregational development, the Office of Networking would help to gather people to create the networks we need. 

Rather than doing direct ministry, the Office of Networking would give grants to creative ministry networks or projects that empower ministry in specified areas, so it would need a budget for ministry grants.  

Fewer program officers would likely be required on churchwide staff under this configuration, because the networking concept allows for the development of local leaders, communicating and sharing resources across networks.  Grants from the Networking office would empower this leadership and sharing.  Networking would help ensure that the transition to a leaner churchwide structure doesn’t reduce ministry resources available – in fact, it might even increase them, because networks involve many more people who are passionate about and expert in a ministry area than a lone Program Officer. 

An Episcopal Ministry Network website could showcase all the different ministry opportunities and resources available churchwide, including items such as:
  • Stewardship resources from TENS and the Episcopal Church Foundation;
  • Christian Formation resources from Forma and from unofficial Episcopal-affiliated groups like Leader Resources, Church Publishing, Forward Movement, etc.;
  • Resources for empowering ethnic ministries;
  • Training and leadership resources for church planting;
  • Leadership and congregational development resources;
  • And so on. 

And remember what I said in yesterday’s post?  The REAL problem isn’t the budget.  The REAL problem is our need to refocus on mission, ministry, and evangelism, to reach new generations and populations.  Additional attention to networking at a churchwide level will allow us to address the REAL problem by giving local ministries the resources they need to refocus on mission, ministry, and evangelism.  And that’s a win-win all around.

Stay tuned for tomorrow's post:  About That Elephant.

Sunday, April 29, 2012

Deck Chairs


Here’s a multiple-choice question for you.  As the Titanic encountered some difficulties the night of April 14-15, 1912, the problem was:

A.  Deck chairs were getting disarranged by the way the ship was listing at an odd angle.

B.  It was rather cold outside, and the chill in the air wasn’t helped by the cold water splashing up over the side of the ship.

C.  All those noisy people up on deck were creating quite a traffic pileup as people tried to get into the lifeboats.

D.  The ship had hit an iceberg and was sinking fast.

If you guessed D – bing bing bing!  You’re right!  Those other difficulties were not the problem – they were symptoms of the problem. 

Now, let’s try another one.  As The Episcopal Church faces some challenges in the next triennium, the problem is:

A.  General Convention costs too much.

B.  The budget process is incompetent, untransparent, and error-ridden.

C.  The churchwide structure has gotten too big and too costly.

D.  The church’s membership has declined precipitously over the past 10 years, leading to steep drop-offs in attendance and financial support at all levels of the church organizational structure.

Surprise, surprise – the answer once again is D!  Bing bing bing!  Those other difficulties aren’t the problem – they are symptoms of the problem.  We have declined in attendance, membership and financial support, and the resulting anxiety has led to huge budget difficulties and the need to revamp our church structure.

Now, it is important to address all the difficulties we face.  But let’s don’t fool ourselves that the problem is, say, that General Convention costs too much, or that the Church Center employs too many people.  The problem is much bigger than that.  The problem is that the culture has shifted around us, we have not shifted with it, and therefore we are in decline.  That’s the problem that underlies all the other problems, and that’s the problem we need to address. 

This is a problem that is shared by all other mainline denominations, and it is a problem that the non-denominational mega-churches are beginning to face, too.  We live in a post-Christendom society, where people don’t see any reason to be “cultural” Christians – those religious, but not necessarily spiritual, regular church attenders and pledgers who filled the pews back in the 1960s.  We don’t have those folks any more.  And our way of evangelism (uh, whatever that is) has not reached the growing immigrant and non-Anglo population in our culture.


These are reasons - they are not excuses.  They are not excuses for our failure to do evangelism with emerging generations and new cultures.  We have not shifted with the culture and learned new ways of doing evangelism.  We have just relied on the surrounding culture to bring people to us.  Times have shifted and they're not coming any more.  We need to learn new ways of reaching new people, and we haven't done it yet.  Because of these failures, our church is in decline.

We can react to this fact in two ways: we can wring our hands, rearrange deck chairs, reorganize structures, and settle in for a long and graceful good-bye.  Or, we can refocus on mission, ministry, and evangelism.  We can focus efforts on people under 35 and on immigrant cultures.  We can look for a spiritual reawakening that will allow the Holy Spirit to guide us into a new era of the church.

Yes, we can react to the other problems too – but until we refocus on mission, ministry, and evangelism, we will be just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic.  

This is the first in a series of posts about The Problem.  Next up: Will the Real Subsidiarity Principle Please Stand Up?

Friday, April 13, 2012

Mission ... Mission ... Mission

“We’re on a mission from God,” proclaimed the famous sages, Dan Aykroyd and John Belushi, as they proceeded to put on cool shades and fedoras, visit a memorable nun, track down the old band members, put Aretha Franklin in a very bad mood, and lead the Chicago police on a wild, wild ride. 

Fortunately for them, Aykroyd and Belushi seemed to have a much clearer understanding of their mission than we Episcopalians do.  “The heartbeat of the church is mission … mission … mission,” said Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori in her sermon at General Convention in 2009.  As I listened to her sermon, I was inspired (though I might argue that the heartbeat of the church is actually the living Christ).  But I also found myself puzzled: what does she mean by “mission”?

Chief Operating Officer Stacy Sauls, who presumably shares the PB’s outlook on mission, clarified their view of mission in his sample “restructuring” resolution for the coming General Convention.  He called for a plan to “facilitate this Church’s faithful engagement in Christ’s mission to proclaim good news to the poor, release to the captives, recovery of sight to the blind, freedom to the oppressed, and the acceptable year of the Lord (Luke 4:18).”  Reading that mission statement from the gospel of Luke broadly, one could say that the mission of the church is to do social justice work.

But what about the other gospels?  What about other statements even within Luke’s gospel?  What about the whole witness of scripture?  Here are some other scriptural mission statements (certainly not a complete list): 

  • “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything that I have commanded you.”  Matthew 28:19-20
  • “The first [commandment] is, ‘Hear, O Israel: the Lord our God, the Lord is one; you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind, and with all your strength.’ The second is this, ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’  There is no other commandment greater than these.”  Mark 12:29-31
  • “Go into all the world and proclaim the good news to the whole creation.”  Mark 16:15
  • “The harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few; therefore ask the Lord of the harvest to send out laborers into his harvest…. Carry no purse, no bag, no sandals; and greet no one on the road…. Whenever you enter a town…cure the sick who are there, and say to them, ‘The kingdom of God has come near to you.’”  Luke 10:2-9
  • “Do this in remembrance of me.”  Luke 22:19
  • “This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you.”  John 15:12
  • “You will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth.”  Acts 1:8
  • “For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes.”  1 Corinthians 11:26


Based on that incomplete list of scriptural mission statements, we could say that the mission of the church includes:  evangelism, worship, formation of disciples, celebration of the sacraments, loving one another, healing, and serving others in need.  Not surprisingly, most churches recognize exactly these actions as integral parts of their mission.  So do the Five Anglican Marks of Mission, more or less:

  • To proclaim the Good News of the Kingdom
  • To teach, baptize and nurture new believers
  • To respond to human need by loving service
  • To seek to transform unjust structures of society
  • To strive to safeguard the integrity of creation and sustain and renew the life of the earth

Why then does the sample resolution limit the church’s mission to a narrow piece of our full biblical mandate? 

In a conversation with Bishop Sauls, he told me that he believes that as we come face to face with the poor, we are formed as disciples – in other words, service to others IS Christian Formation.  This is lovely and true, and I appreciate what he is saying out of his own deep faith and service.  But it is incomplete.  First of all, some Episcopalians ARE poor – we should question our own social location if we start assuming that Christian formation is a matter of coming face to face with these strangers, the poor. Secondly, not everyone has the leisure or financial resources to help the poor to a very large extent - not the average working family, and certainly not your average 10-year-old who needs to learn about Jesus.  Surely we are not depending on people's charity work to do ALL of their Christian Formation.

And third:  Jesus himself, as he proclaimed that mission statement in Luke’s gospel, was quoting Isaiah: he was speaking out of a lifetime of religious education in the Hebrew scriptures that he had studied, memorized, internalized, and applied to life.  Like Jesus, we have to learn it first before we apply it.  And, if we want our church to survive, and thrive, and grow, and serve, we need to help others learn it too.  We can’t just assume that everyone who will ever be Christian already is, and all we have to do is put them (or their money) to work!

If the church neglects to form disciples through evangelism, worship and education, in 50 years we will have no one left to do the acts of loving service to others that comprise what Sauls and Jefferts Schori think of as mission … mission … mission.  It takes disciples to do discipleship work.  And therefore, evangelism and Christian formation need to be at the foundation of our church’s mission. 

We need to recognize that any restructuring of our church will be impoverished indeed if we limit ourselves to only one bit of what Jesus has commanded us to do.  We all have different gifts, and different portions of the mission that we are especially called to fulfill, but together, as a church, as the Body of Christ, we are commanded to do all these things.  Because, you know, we’re on a mission from God. 


RESTRUCTURING FOR MISSION

Happily, we have already defined our mission: General Convention 2009 Resolution D027 did exactly this by adopting the Anglican Marks of Mission and requiring our budget priorities to be based on these Marks.  I can’t see any indication that Executive Council’s proposed budget actually considers these Marks as priorities, but that’s no reason for PB&F or Convention 2012 to let them get away with neglecting the priorities we have already adopted! 

My previous blog post recommended that we adopt a quick fix that freezes administrative costs that are universally agreed to be too high, while maintaining mission-oriented ministries like the Office of Christian Formation.  I believe that this is the right approach for this year.  But it’s a quick fix, and won’t take us very far into the future.  Chief Operating Officer Sauls is absolutely right that the church needs to be restructured for mission, and he is to be congratulated for getting the conversation kicked into high gear.  Let’s talk about how to do this restructuring.

First, let’s define the problem.  Why are we restructuring?  We are restructuring quite simply because the church is in decline.  The financial woes are only a symptom of the underlying problem: declining membership, declining attendance, and aging church membership compared to the population as a whole. 

We can run through all the usual excuses: all the mainline denominations are declining, many conservatives left amid a whole bunch of conflict, new generations aren’t interested in institutions, etc.  In other words, it’s not our fault.  To which I say:  Whatever.  There are plenty of people out there who have not had their lives transformed by Jesus Christ.  As Jesus says in Luke 10:2:  “The harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few; therefore ask the Lord of the harvest to send out laborers into his harvest.”  We are the laborers – the harvest is there.  We need to ask God to send us out. 

That’s why we’re restructuring.  We’re getting back to our roots.  It’s time to start accomplishing the mission Jesus is sending us to do.  

Several proposals have been floated for restructuring.

Hold a Special Constitutional Convention devoted to restructuring.  I am extremely skeptical of this idea.  It’s too expensive, for one thing.  And I truly believe that without a carefully designed and mission-oriented grassroots change process preceding a restructuring convention, change will not occur.  That’s the lesson of what Rabbi Edwin Friedman calls “homeostasis”: a system will naturally work to protect the balance it has already achieved, whether that balance is healthy or not.  I believe that a special convention without a great deal of underlying change work would simply result in all the interest groups in the church rising up to protect themselves and maintain their current balance.  No real change would happen.  We need to make a plan for change that is widely agreed upon and includes the voices of a wide variety of people before trying to legislate change. 

Rearrange the way General Convention works.  This includes suggestions like unicameral legislature, revised role of Presiding Bishop, fewer meetings, smaller deputations, ad hoc task forces rather than standing commissions, much more work done electronically, etc.  All interesting proposals to consider, all potentially useful.  But they won't address the core of the problem.  General Convention could operate more efficiently, but that won’t send out laborers into God’s harvest.  It won’t cause our church to grow.  It won’t bring the gospel to new generations.  It won’t increase our acts of loving service to those in need.  Not that we shouldn’t consider doing these things – we should.  New times and new technologies call for new ways of meeting and making decisions, and in this day and age, we need to be much more flexible than an every-three-years meeting allows.  But we should not mistake these changes for re-orienting ourselves toward mission.  We need to plan for how to achieve our mission, then make the structural changes to empower that mission. 

Pass a budget resolution that requires a high percentage of revenues to be devoted to mission.  A feel-good resolution!  Hurray!  And I agree with it!  That is, as long as I agree with how it defines “mission.”  But wait, what are we going to do about the Manhattan office building known as 815 and its related debt service?  What about canonically required work such as Title IV cases, as well as things that the churchwide office clearly should be doing such as ecumenical work, Anglican Communion relations and Federal Ministries?  What about the role of the Church Center in empowering mission at the local level?  We would plunge the church into turmoil without a grown-up, serious plan for how to address these grown-up, serious issues.  

Significantly lower the “asking” from the dioceses to allow more money to be used for local mission.  Good idea.  But – we need to adopt mission priorities at every level of the church, and we need to empower mission in the way that is most efficient for each level.  We should not, say, throw out Christian Formation at the churchwide level without any plan for how the other levels are going to get that part of our mission done.  Christian Formation is an absolutely vital component of our church’s mission, and we need to make sure it happens.  That means that we need to have a plan in place for how to empower this mission, and we need to have a transition time to get the new plan up and running before we just let the old plan go. 

Do you see a common theme running through all these critiques?  I do.  We need a plan.  We need a plan that brings in the voices of laypeople, deacons, priests and bishops.  We need a plan that concentrates on particular ministry areas and particular administrative issues.  We need a plan that points us toward change for the 21st century. 

Here is what I think such a plan should involve:

1.  A steering group of not more than 12 complete outsiders to church structures.  By outsiders, I mean dedicated Episcopalians, entrepreneurial thinkers and doers, who are not involved in Church Center work or high-level churchwide politics or standing commissions.  If you’re standing on the carpet, you can’t make the carpet fly.  These need to be people who love the church, understand the mission, but are not personally invested in current structures. 

2.  This steering group would have the power to appoint several blue-ribbon panels:

     > A panel of real estate experts who would make recommendations about what to do about 815 (the building), including looking at options of selling it, leasing it, and other creative possibilities I don’t know about.  In the hopes that something could be done about this behemoth before the next General Convention, we need to make sure that Executive Council has the power to act on any offers that might come in, and understands that the will of Convention is that we should divest ourselves of this building.  There should be no more argument about this.  We are not going to be a New York corporate hierarchical-model church any more.  We are going to be a mission-focused church.

     > A group of investigators that looks at options for relocating the churchwide structure, including cost, accessibility to airports, closeness to important power structures for our church, and available resources.  How about using vacant space at Washington National Cathedral?  How about using vacant space at Seabury Western Seminary?  And so on.  (I cite those two examples having no idea whether they are practical ideas, but offering them as the kind of options we should be considering.)  Again, Executive Council should be empowered to make a move on this recommendation as soon as 815 is disposed of.   

     > A panel of human resources and other experts who would look at the churchwide staff structure and recommend options for streamlining, outsourcing, and closing unnecessary offices.  In addition, this panel would carefully delineate those functions – such as, say, ecumenical relations – that absolutely must be carried out by the churchwide office, and would recommend the staffing and other resources needed to carry out those functions.  Executive Council should be empowered to make an immediate move. 

     >  A panel of people who look at our churchwide governing structures and make recommendations for different ways of operating, including possibilities of reducing standing commissions, using more electronic meetings and communications, considering the size of deputations and frequency of meetings, etc.  Constitutional changes would be required if any changes are made, so these recommendations would need to be considered by Convention.  Bishop Sauls tells me that the Diocese of San Diego has put forth an interesting resolution (which I haven't seen) that would make this possible in 3 years rather than 6. 

3.  Now, back to the steering group.  What are they doing?  They are leading a churchwide visioning process that is based in Bible study, prayer, and deep discernment of where the Holy Spirit is leading people in their ministries.  They are holding out the Anglican Marks of Mission as a reasonable summary of mission in our church, and they are training facilitators to lead a visioning process, gathering input from people in the church for how to achieve this mission. Why a churchwide visioning process?  Because we need input from the grassroots levels of the church, guided by the Holy Spirit.  Without broad-based input and buy-in at every level of the church, any proposals for change would not truly cause change.  They would be defeated or sabotaged.  This is the lesson of Rabbi Edwin Friedman's concept of homeostasis.  Remember, it is a key part of this program that the visioning process be led by outsiders.  Insiders to the structure of the church, however faithful and well-meaning we know they are, will be led to protect current structures.  All change must be on the table.

     a.  The visioning process would be open to any group that wants to participate – interest groups around particular ministry areas, dioceses, provinces, local parishes, seminaries, etc. 

     b.  Trained facilitators would lead the interest groups in a spiritually-focused discernment process that begins with significant, in-depth, inductive Bible study and prayer around mission-focused passages (with the caveat that no one Bible passage encompasses the full scope of God’s commission to us, so multiple passages must be considered). 

     c.  The visioning process would continue with a set of questions and exercises.  The purpose would be to discern answers to how God is leading the group, and the wider church, to achieve its mission.  What do we dream of?  What do we hope for?  Where are we now?  What would it take to get where we want to be?  What kind of support does the group need from diocesan, provincial, and churchwide structures?  How much money, personnel, and physical structures will it require? 

     d.  The facilitators would bring reports back to the steering group, which would assimilate the feedback and undergo a similar visioning process of its own.  The steering group would make a report to the wider church.  That report would include recommendations for:

          > The “panel of expert” recommendations, above.
          > The best structure for mission in the defined Marks of Mission areas.
          > Ways to flatten the current hierarchical structure so that the Church Center does not control, but rather empowers, ministry at all levels of the church.
          > Criteria for funding ministry being done by local parishes, by dioceses, by provinces and by networks within the church.  A Mission Fund would be established, using a very high percentage of revenues collected from the dioceses and from the endowment, and empowered to give grants for ministry (carried out by local groups or churchwide independent networks) that meet carefully defined Marks of Mission criteria. 
          > A better budget process that would give the church time and leadership necessary to create a mission-focused budget, and would not demand that PB&F be the de facto determiner of all churchwide mission by its last-minute Convention decisions about what to fund or not to fund.  Asking this of PB&F is not fair to them, or to the church.
          > A strategic fundraising plan, not the “how” of fundraising (which would be the work of a Development Office), but the “what for.”  What are our strategic priorities?  How much will they cost?  How can we express them as a dream that others will want to participate in?  The Development Office will need a menu of dreams to present to potential donors. 
          > Possibly: recommendations for leadership training.  How are we going to recruit, train, and equip the kind of young entrepreneurial leaders who will be needed for the new church we are creating? 

This report would be available by summer 2014, and ready for the entire church to discuss and assimilate for a full year before General Convention 2015.  In 2015, we vote – and may the best plan win.  That is to say – God’s plan.  Because we're on a mission from God.  

Monday, March 26, 2012

Jarndyce vs. Jarndyce and Short-Term Solutions to Long-Term Problems

Reading the proposed budget for The Episcopal Church for the next triennium, I am reminded of the classic Dickens novel, Bleak House.  The plot centers around a loosely connected family named the Jarndyces.  Long ago, some ancestor died and left a valuable estate, and since then, various branches of the family have been caught up in the legal case Jarndyce vs. Jarndyce, questioning which of them is the rightful heir.  The plot meanders through labyrinthine Dickensian twists, until at last, the lawsuit ends.  Not by determining an answer, though – by using up the entire estate in legal fees.  Once the last hour has been billed, there is no more property to bicker over, and the lawsuit dies. 

Well, you could say The Episcopal Church is caught up in a never-ending labyrinth of plot twists, and meanwhile, our resources are being eaten up by administrative costs.  In a world that is rapidly changing, in which hierarchical institutions are being flattened, and new forms of church are bubbling up, our churchwide structure is caught up in a top-heavy model of ministry that simply eats up money.  I don’t believe God will let this church die – but let’s don’t let it get that close.  Let’s think about mission.

It may seem mundane to talk about mission in terms of a budget.  But the way we allocate our treasure shows where our hearts will be.  So let’s talk about allocation of financial resources at the churchwide level. First, we need to accept as the unvarnished truth the fact that our church is declining precipitously in attendance and finances, while aging significantly in comparison to the population.  We have neglected evangelism and forming new disciples, especially among the younger generations.  As a result, if we do not take some significant and strategic actions now, our church will continue its graceful decline, right into oblivion.  Jarndyce vs. Jarndyce!  

At the same time, as I noted here, Administration and Governance Costs together comprise 65% of the money that dioceses and others send to the national church structure, at least in Executive Council’s proposed budget.  Not exactly an inspiring statement of mission!    Just take one look at the category of costs called “Finance.”  Out of a total triennial budget of $104 million, Finance Costs are $15 million, over 14%.  Of that amount, $8.7 million is payment of principal and interest on the debt, most of which finances the Manhattan office building known as “815,” which houses a portion of our administrative offices.  It costs another $7.3 million just to run the Treasurer’s and Controller’s Offices.   At the same time, program offices like Christian Formation (that is, all youth and campus ministries, and all formation offices), which currently cost much less than the finance offices, have been eliminated. 

It’s like the dioceses are sending money to 815 so they can spend the money counting the money. 

This is an unsustainable situation.  It’s Jarndyce vs. Jarndyce.  Let’s talk about solutions.

Short-Term Solutions

According to Ron Haifetz' theory of leadership (for a brief explanation, see the Ron Haifetz videos posted on the HoD website), problems can be divided into technical problems (those we know how to fix within our current structures) and adaptive challenges (those that require a complete reorientation at all levels of an organization).  In the short time left between now and General Convention 2012, I do not believe we have time to meet most of the adaptive challenges in front of The Episcopal Church, though we can begin shifting our priorities.  We DO have time for some technical solutions to the problems in this proposed budget.  


But what is reasonable to achieve with technical budget fixes?  In the short term, it would be a mistake to try to solve adaptive challenges with technical fixes.  This is what will happen if we try to make major reorganizational decisions by budget-cutting. 

How do we know this would be a huge mistake?  That’s exactly what we did in 2009!  Without foresight, vision, or strategic planning, huge budget cuts were made that caused numerous churchwide employees to lose their jobs, and numerous programs (many of which had just been legislated into existence at the very same convention) to be shut down. 

Why are we thinking about doing the same thing again?

All right, I won’t scratch my head and ask what’s been going on the last three years.  I won’t ask why we haven’t done some proactive planning.  I won’t ask why we’re falling into exactly the same trap now.

Here’s what I want to ask:  isn’t there a better way to do this?

Yes, there is.  And I think the process falls into two stages.

Short Term: avoid making major shifts.  The Christian Formation office was cut under the rationale that such things are better done at the local level.  I don’t agree, because I think it is tremendously short-sighted for a church that is suffering from failure to form new disciples (especially among the young), and from aging demographics, to cut youth and college programming.  Strategic vision for the future would require increased, not decreased, resources for youth/young adult ministries, at all levels.  True, this is a ministry that is essentially done at the local level - but we can't simply remove all its churchwide supports and expect it to thrive on its own without strategic work to make sure other structures are in place to support it.    

But that’s my argument; you can disagree.  Here’s the point: if we cut Christian Formation in this budget, we are making a huge long-term decision based on narrow short-term thinking.    

Short-term, it is perfectly possible to balance this budget without cutting Christian Formation.  We can do this through our existing legislative structures, by advocating through PB&F public hearings, or even proposing an alternative budget.  To understand how a technical fix to this budget might work, you need to understand some basic accounting issues with the way this budget was put together.  Sorry about the accounting stuff, but here goes:

> This budget looks balanced, but it is actually a deficit budget of $1,250,000.  This is because Executive Council used money from the Endowment ($3,766,000) to fund a new Development Office – but the cost of the Development Office was incorrectly listed.  See line 366 of the budget: only $2,516,300 of costs are listed.  As a result, in effect, this budget uses Endowment Income designated for the Development Office to fund operating expenses – bad move.  $1,250,000 needs to be cut.

> On the other hand, there is one large and rather strange adding error.  The total for line 689 is overstated by $1,412,770.  I asked Chief Operating Officer Stacy Sauls and Treasurer Kurt Barnes for an explanation of this discrepancy (and I thank them for their careful attention to my question).  It seems that in the rush of approving the budget, Executive Council first deleted 10% from this area and then may have decided to add it back in - but the details are not clear and no one really seems to know.  Absent an explanation, we have an opportunity for painless budget-cutting: whatever this unexplained figure represents, no one has complained about its absence.  Let's cut it from the budget.    

> Once the above items are corrected, the remainder of the budget can be balanced by freezing most administrative costs (not increasing them as this budget proposes to do, for God’s sake: this budget actually proposes a 3% per year raise for Church Center employees, in a time of falling revenues when many or most local church employee salaries are frozen).  By freezing most administrative costs, we can restore most of the costs of Christian Formation, the Board of Examining Chaplains, and Jubilee Ministries.  This is all possible because Executive Council has already done some significant budget-cutting, including cuts to funding for CCABs, which seems reasonable.  Here are sample figures for one way this might work (though I do not have access to  all the details underlying the proposed budget figures; PB&F does, I hope, and would be able to refine these figures):


Proposed Increases / (Decreases) to Expense:
PB Office Staff Costs ($364,000)
Bishop Europe ($50,000)
General Board of Examining Chaplains $150,000
House of Deputies Staff Costs ($212,000)
Office of Gen Conv Staff Costs ($335,000)
Archives Staff Costs ($300,000)
Chief Operating Officer Staff Costs ($180,000)
Controller Staff Costs ($420,000)
Treasurer Staff Costs ($119,000)
Facilities Management ($200,000)
Human Resources Staff Costs ($270,000)
Mission Technology Staff Costs ($150,000)
Correct Error Development Office $1,250,000
Restore Jubilee Ministries $650,000
Restore Christian Formation $2,500,000
Anglican Communion Staff Costs ($200,000)
Correct Error Grants Covenants Approp ($1,412,770)
Office of Government Relations ($650,000)
Net Increases / (Decreases) ($312,770)


All we have done here is kept major churchwide programs in place.  Significant cost-cutting between the last triennium and this triennium in some areas has been accomplished, because that cost-cutting was already in the proposed budget.  Comparing my changes (above) to the proposed budget,  we have not cut any further administrative expenses – we have just refused to increase them.  That’s reasonable, in a time of budget-cutting!  There’s even a little money left over.

By making these changes, we avoid making long-term decisions based on short-term budget shortfalls.  We don't try to apply a technical Band-aid to an adaptive challenge.  We give ourselves time to make long-term plans in the next triennium.  And, if it is really true that some of these ministries would be better done on the diocesan or local level, well, we give those networks time to formulate plans for how to get that done. 

Right now, if we cut youth and campus ministries, there is no local, diocesan, or provincial structure in place to take over those functions.  That is a recipe for disaster.  Especially while we increase administrative costs.  The proposed budget would simply suck more money away from mission into administration: the Episcopal version of Jarndyce vs. Jarndyce. 

Once we have made these short-term technical fixes, we have time to think about the adaptive challenges ahead of us.  That will be the subject of my next post: Long-Term Thinking.

Friday, March 23, 2012

The Perfect Candidate

Taking a break from writing about the budget ... let's talk about interviewing for a job.  I wrote a status update on Facebook yesterday about my difficult experiences interviewing people for positions at my church.  No need to repeat that here, but I confess I am surprised at how many young people don't know basic strategies for interviewing.  I guess they're not teaching it any more in schools, the way they used to.

Anyway, if you are looking for a job ... and many young people are, in this economy ... it might help you to know what I am (and others like me are) looking for and experiencing.  So, here goes.

First, let's talk about the basics.

  • Spell check your resume.  It's free!  And I am going to be looking to see whether you are going to embarrass me when you send out emails full of spelling and grammatical errors.  (Honestly - I actually had someone misspell his own name on his resume.  I know because he spelled it two different ways in two different places.)
  • Write me a cover letter - not a 2-line email saying, "Here's my resume."  Tell me why you are excited about this position and why I should be excited about you.  Highlight specific experiences you've had that are similar to the job I'm trying to fill.  Tell me you hope to talk to me soon.  Include that cover letter as a Word or pdf attachment and not just as part of your email, because I am going to want to save the cover letter and resume, and if I like you, forward them on to other members of my search committee.  Use spell check!
  • Show up early.  Ten minutes early is good.  If you're late, you'll inconvenience me, because I have arranged my schedule around you.  But more importantly, you'll make me think that you're one of those flaky people who don't keep their commitments.  I don't want flaky people on my team.  
  • Dress a little better than the position requires.  I know, you're interviewing for, say, a youth position, and youth dress casually.  But remember, you are dressing not just for the the youth, but also for their parents.  And I am going to be looking at you to see whether both the youth and their parents will respond well to you.  And I sure don't want to be sitting there thinking, OK, my first come-to-Jesus meeting with this person is going to have to be about her habit of wearing low-cut, revealing clothing to church.  Or his habit of wearing grunge clothing.  Or whatever.  
  • Do not ask me in the first paragraph, or even in the first interview, what the salary is.  I will think that you're interested in renting a nice apartment or buying a nice car, instead of in doing the ministry that I am looking for someone to do.  I actually do understand that you need a salary to live on.  If I like you, I will invite you to come for a second interview.  At that point, if it is an imposition on your time to come to a second interview - say, if you have to travel to get here - then you can ask me, delicately, about the salary range.  I am not going to tell you the specific salary, even then, but I will give you a general idea.  I won't know the specific salary I am willing to offer you until I have decided how well you will fit on our team.  
  • Try, at least try, to be interested in the job I am actually interviewing you for, and not some other job it may lead to at some other organization at some time in the future.  Being interested in advancement is a fine thing, but being interested in personal advancement at the expense of my church is not.  The sooner you are planning to move on to something else, the bigger the liability, and the mistake, hiring you will turn out to be.  I want to know that you are interested in this job, at this church.  
  • Know something about me, my church, and the position I am interviewing you for, before we talk.  It's all there on our website.  I will want to know that you have thoroughly read the position description and all the links it points to, and I will give you bonus points if you ask specific questions about them.  I will give you extra gold stars if you have noticed other things on our website, not directly related to this position, but things you find exciting, inspiring, or interesting.  Ask questions about these things!  Show me you've noticed!  
OK, now that the basics are out of the way, I want to give you a little insight into what's going through my mind as I interview you.
  • This interview thing?  This is the biggest pain in my neck right now.  I really, really want to fill the job vacancy I have so I can create a solid team, which can go back to doing the work we love to do.  I have been praying (hoping, wishing, worrying) that the right person would show up, pronto.  That means, when you walk in the door, I want you to succeed.  I want you to be the one.  
  • But listen - that doesn't mean that I want just anyone to fill this position.  I'm not hiring someone to flip hamburgers.  I am hiring someone who will be a part of a team.  I want someone who will build relationships, with the staff and with our customers, that is, our church members and our surrounding community.  So - I am not hiring someone who is in this for the short term.  If you build great relationships, and then leave after a year, I am worse off than before I hired you.  Don't give me the impression that that's what you are planning to do.
  • That means that I am going to be listening hard for two things: are you called to do this kind of ministry, is this something you love and have a passion for?  And, are you in this for the long haul?  If you tell me that you're just looking for something for a year or two, while you find yourself, then I'm going to be pretty sure that you are not called to do this ministry.  I'm not going to hire someone on a trial basis, while we both figure out if it's going to work.  
  • Let's talk about calling.  In my business, the faith business, we believe that God gives us spiritual gifts and calls us to use them in specific ways.  Therefore, I am looking for the person who is called.  In business, you would say this is a person who has a passion for exactly this kind of work, and the skills required to do it.  I am ideally looking for someone who has found herself/himself doing exactly this kind of thing in various ways for a long time.  That doesn't mean you've held exactly this job before.  It does mean that you've shown these gifts and enjoyed this kind of work, as a volunteer, a camp counselor, an extracurricular leader, etc.  Show me and tell me what you've done that demonstrates your calling for this kind of work.
  • If you get past the initial set of questions with me, I am going to ask you to give me examples of two things: (1) leadership and (2) initiative.  Examples - that means stories.  I want to hear you tell the stories of things you've done really well.  Come prepared to tell them.
  • If I really, really like you, I will also ask you to tell me the story of something you've failed at, and what you have learned from it.  Failure is the best learning.  Don't make up some BS about how you failed to be humble enough about how great you are.  I know the B-school routine.  Please do tell me something that you have failed and learned from.  We all fail, from time to time. I want to understand that you are open to growth and learning.    
  • You know what else I want to know about?  Your work ethic.  I want to know that you will show up when you say you will, and work the hours I am paying you to work.  I will look favorably on those two years in high school you spent working at McDonald's, because I will know that they didn't put up with you showing up late or deciding to sleep in on a whim.  Tell me how you are willing to put in hours to get the job done right.  There is occasional overtime in this position, and there are irregular hours.  I will tell you the hours are flexible, and it is true.  But I want to know going in that you will be there when you say you will, and you will put in the hours that you are paid for, and you will consider yourself a part of a professional team, and act professionally.  
  • This is a church.  I am going to want to know about your faith life.  What draws you to this church, why do you follow Jesus, what do you think is important about being part of a church?  What do you see as the church's mission?  Why should people be part of it?  I will want to hear you say that you have been praying about this job opportunity.  
  • Tell me your vision for this position.  What would you do to make it a terrific ministry?  What ideas do you have to contribute to this organization?  How will you help transform people's lives?  How will you help people come to know Christ?  I really want to know this.  Because I want you to be the minister, not the robot who does what I tell you to do.  I want to turn you loose and watch you blossom as you do what you're called to do.  Show me that you're a leader, with ideas, creativity, and faith.  
Maybe you're not looking for a church position, and some of the things I've said don't apply to you.  But think about what I've said, and go into your next interview ready to shine.  And God bless you in your next ministry.

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

What Would a Mission-Oriented Budget Process Look Like?

A budget is a missionary document.  Like it or not, the budget states what our true priorities are.  As Jesus said, “Where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.”  Wherever we put our treasure, is where our hearts are guaranteed to end up.  So – it follows that we need to put our treasure where we want our hearts to be. 

So, a budget states our missionary priorities.  Unfortunately, too often, a budget is simply a rehash of whatever happened last year, plus some sort of adjustment for inflation (cost increases, salary raises, or whatever).  Thus, our missionary priorities are built on the backs of the past, and we end up doing whatever we did last year, plus some (or, recently, in DFMS, minus some).  In a paradigm like this, it becomes very hard to turn a very large ship.

So what happens when times change?  When it is time for adaptive change, not just technical change (in Ron Heifetz’ terms)?  When we need to rethink our mission, our actions, and our paradigms?

In a situation like that – which, in The Episcopal Church, is the situation we are in – a same-as-last-year-plus-a-little (or minus-a-little) approach is exactly the wrong approach.  Remember that where our treasure is, there our hearts will be also.  If we don’t change our way of allocating treasure, we will continue inexorably on the course we are on: decline. 

Unfortunately, our budget process in TEC is almost guaranteed to keep us in decline.  If I understand it correctly, it goes something like this:


  • The treasurer's office laboriously estimates next triennium's income, adds up all the expenses it can anticipate, and enters it all in a massive spreadsheet that it presents to Executive Council.

  • Executive Council, composed of a group of people with varying degrees of financial expertise, very little time to work, and lots of other tasks to accomplish, works through the numbers it is given as best it can, asks questions, makes a few changes, and creates a budget proposal.  Of necessity, the budget is based on last year’s expenses, because there has been no overarching consideration of mission - only ad hoc discussions as Executive Council members looked at the numbers they were given.  Council does the best they can with the limited information they have.


  •          The Program, Budget, & Finance Committee takes the proposed budget and begins to massage it.  At General Convention, they hold a series of hearings, at which the best-organized and most unanimous groups, those with the most articulate supporters, get the most air time and attention. 


  •           In the waning hours of Convention, PB&F proposes a revised budget to General Convention.  That budget is similar to Executive Council’s proposal, with pluses or minuses for what PB&F heard in the hearings. 


  •            General Convention may make minor tweaks to PB&F’s proposal, but because the Convention is nearly concluded and cannot adjourn without a budget, the budget passes with little enthusiasm.  This budget may have little relationship to initiatives that were passed earlier in the Convention.  As it turns out, much of the previous legislative work is for naught.  The only thing that counts at an operational level is whether projects were funded.  (Example: at GC ’09, all of the resolutions of the Evangelism Committee, on which I served, were passed with high levels of support.  Almost none of them were funded; the Evangelism Officer, who would have taken on these projects, lost his job; the only project funded was the Latino/Hispanic initiative, which had numerous well-organized supporters speaking in support in hearings and on the floor, and got 10% of its budget request.  Note: I worked hard on the Latino/Hispanic resolution, and supported it enthusiastically.  But I supported the other Evangelism resolutions also, and they all died for lack of funding.) 


  •          The church continues to trundle on, with enthusiastic dreams not funded.  In fact, some of those dreams may never have been articulated because some of the folks most deeply involved in the ministries were never consulted.  The ship goes meandering slowly on, in the same direction it was already going. 

So what would a mission-oriented budget process look like?  First of all, we need to do away with the assumption that what we did last year should have any relation at all to what we do this year.  No more last-year-plus-a-little.  And for that matter, no more last-year-minus-a-little.  No references to last year at all. 

Now I realize that I am not an 815 insider, or an Executive Council insider, or any kind of expert on the inner workings of DFMS.  But, to me, this is not rocket science.  In the financial straits we are in, it is vitally important that we ensure that our limited financial resources go to fund mission priorities that can transform the church.  After all, where our treasure is, there our hearts will be also.  A mission-oriented budget approach might look like this:

  • At the beginning of each triennium, Executive Council undergoes a visioning process.  In the light of decisions made at the last General Convention, what should be the priorities of the church?  Where is God leading us at this moment in our history?  Where does God want our hearts to be?  That's where we need to put our treasure.  Executive Council names its top mission and budget priorities for the coming triennium.  


  •            Next, Executive Council asks each department or mission group also to undergo a visioning process, in conjunction with the group’s networks of influence in the wider church.  The Formation Officers, for instance, would work within their own group and would also consult with groups like NAECED (now Forma).  The Stewardship Officer would consult with The Episcopal Network for Stewardship and the Episcopal Church Foundation.  What is their mission, and what activities are vital to achieving this mission? 


  •           Once each mission group has defined its mission, ask them to explain how their mission helps to further the church’s mission.  For convenience, General Convention has already defined TEC’s mission as the Five Anglican Marks of Mission.  Executive Council might choose to add other vital components of the DFMS mission, such as relationships with other churches of the Anglican Communion, ecumenical relationships, governance by all orders of ministry,  fiscal responsibility, etc.  Each mission group needs to explain how their mission helps to advance Executive Council’s defined components of mission.


  •            Now that each mission group has defined and justified its mission, it needs to explain what its mission will cost.  It will do this in two interrelated ways:

o   Its basic budget request.  What is the bare minimum amount the mission group needs to fulfill its mission?  What would allow it to do maintenance and no more?  The group needs to justify the full amount it is requesting, line by line, position by position.  It must be an absolute rule that its request does not refer to last year’s budget.  This is the basis of zero-based budgeting.  Your request starts from zero, and you justify it from there. 

o   Its “dream” request.  If there were no limits in resources, personnel or time, what would the group like to achieve?  How could they creatively work with other church networks?  What would they love to do, if only they could?  Let them dream about the possibilities.  Then let them put a dollar figure on the possibilities, with a full explanation of what the dream projects would accomplish.  If the group has no dreams – well, that speaks for itself. 


  •            Please note that every mission group that needs funding must go through the same process – every administrative department, every CCAB.  What are they hoping to accomplish to further the church’s mission?


  •            Executive Council may have some dreams of its own – a development office, say, or ensuring greater fiscal responsibility by paying down some debt.  Executive Council will also have to articulate these dreams and how they help to advance the church’s mission. 


  •            Executive Council’s budget group receives the mission statements, the definition of how those missions achieve the church’s priorities, the basic and the dream requests.  The budget group weighs these requests against projected revenue.  And then the budget group begins to set priorities.  How central is the mission of each group to the mission of TEC?  How well has the group worked with other networks in the church to empower diocesan and local mission?  How captivating are the dreams?  How do all the amounts balance out, dreams against dollars?  Are there some big dreams that can be achieved for moderate dollars, or very few dollars?  Fund them!  Are there some big dollar amounts that don’t seem to map well to the church’s mission priorities?  Eliminate them!  Executive Council creates a budget that uses the funds available to meet the mission priorities that are most vital.  Administrative support is funded as necessary to support other mission groups. 


  •             Executive Council creates a budget and forwards it, along with all the budget information, including dreams and mission statements, to PB&F.  This communication process will be very important, perhaps requiring in-depth meetings so that PB&F members can hear what exciting and vital things are contained within this budget proposal.  Mission groups who want to have their dreams funded will work with networks within the church to have appropriate resolutions formulated and passed, and supporters mobilized to speak in favor.  This will require them to do consciousness-raising work in the wider church. 


  •            PB&F will make a budget proposal four days before the end of convention.  This will be possible because significant advance work will have gone into the dreams and requirements that make up this budget.  This advance proposal will mean that there will be time to make changes on the floor; however, proposed changes must be bottom-line-neutral.  That is, if they propose to increase an expense item, they must cut another expense item or increase a revenue item to counterbalance it. 


  •            With plenty of time to consider, General Convention will decide on the budget.  It will be Executive Council’s job to communicate the dreams and priorities and hold the mission groups accountable to achieve what they said they would achieve.  Employee evaluations, raises, and continuance of employment will be based on these benchmarks. 

Under this revised budgeting method, you have not assumed that last year’s assumptions will still hold true.  You have a group of people that has worked hard to understand its own mission and how it relates to the mission of the larger church.  You have employees and networks that have dreamed about the possibilities and about ways they can achieve them. You have begun to point a very large ship in a whole new direction.